American Cuisine
Muffuletta Sandwich
By Antoine Fontenot, RecipeOK Test Kitchen
Rate this recipe
The muffuletta was born in 1906 at Central Grocery, a Sicilian import store on Decatur Street in New Orleans' French Quarter, where owner Salvatore Lupo noticed Sicilian farmers and dockworkers buying salami, cheese, olive salad, and round sesame loaves separately and eating them standing up at the counter. Lupo combined the ingredients into a single sandwich named after the muffuletta loaf itself — a squat, round, sesame-crusted Sicilian bread — and it became a fixture of the French Quarter lunch crowd almost overnight. What sets a real muffuletta apart from any other Italian cold-cut sandwich is the olive salad: a chunky, garlicky, vinegar-bright mix of olives, giardiniera-style vegetables, and herbs that's spread generously over both cut sides of the bread rather than served on the side. The salad's oil and acidity slowly soak into the crumb as the sandwich rests, which is why muffulettas are traditionally wrapped and left for at least thirty minutes (some purists insist on a few hours) before slicing — the wait is what turns a stack of deli meat into something greater than its parts. It remains one of New Orleans' most identifiable foods, served cold, cut into quarters, and eaten as a shareable centerpiece at po-boy shops, delis, and family gatherings across the city and beyond.
Ingredients
Serves 4Instructions
- 1
In a bowl, combine the chopped olives, sun-dried tomatoes, capers, minced garlic, olive oil, and balsamic vinegar. Mix well to create the olive salad.
- 2
Slice the muffuletta bread loaf in half horizontally.
- 3
Spread the olive salad generously over both cut sides of the bread, pressing it into the soft crumb so the juices soak in.
- 4
On the bottom half of the bread, layer the salami, ham, mortadella, provolone, and mozzarella cheese.
- 5
Place the top half of the bread on the sandwich.
- 6
Wrap the entire sandwich tightly in plastic wrap or foil. For best results, let it rest for at least 30 minutes (or up to a few hours) to allow the flavors to meld.
- 7
Unwrap the sandwich, cut it into wedges (quarters), and serve.
- 8
Cook whole-cut meat until it reaches an internal temperature of 145°F (63°C) on a food thermometer, per USDA guidance.
Chef's Tips
- ✦ Don't skip the resting step — wrapping the sandwich tightly and letting it sit for at least 30 minutes (up to a few hours in the fridge) is what allows the olive salad's oil and vinegar to soak into the bread, which is essential to the sandwich's character.
- ✦ Make the olive salad a day ahead if you can; like a marinade, it only gets better as the garlic and vinegar mellow into the olives overnight.
- ✦ Press down firmly when wrapping the sandwich in plastic wrap or foil — light compression helps the layers meld and makes for cleaner wedge cuts.
- ✦ Use a serrated bread knife and saw gently through the loaf rather than pressing straight down, especially once it's stuffed, to avoid squeezing the filling out the sides.
Ingredient Substitutions
-
muffuletta loaf → focaccia or a large round sesame semolina loaf
look for a sturdy, slightly dense bread that can hold up to the oily olive salad
-
mortadella → capicola or additional salami
capicola adds a spicier edge if mortadella isn't available
-
mixed olives → jarred giardiniera blended with green olives
adds extra pickled-vegetable crunch closer to some New Orleans grocers' versions
-
provolone cheese → aged Asiago or mild cheddar
keep at least one sharper cheese in the mix for flavor contrast
Tags
Frequently Asked Questions
What is muffuletta olive salad made of? ▼
A traditional muffuletta olive salad combines chopped green and black olives, garlic, capers, olive oil, and vinegar, often with the addition of chopped celery, cauliflower, or carrots (giardiniera-style). This recipe uses a simplified version with mixed olives, sun-dried tomatoes, capers, garlic, olive oil, and balsamic vinegar.
Why do you need to let a muffuletta sandwich rest before eating it? ▼
Resting lets the olive salad's oil and vinegar soak into the bread, which softens the crumb slightly and melds the flavors of the meats, cheese, and salad together. A muffuletta eaten immediately after assembly tastes noticeably less cohesive than one that's rested 30 minutes to a few hours.
Can I make a muffuletta sandwich the night before serving it? ▼
Yes — in fact many New Orleans delis recommend it. Wrap tightly and refrigerate overnight, then bring to room temperature for about 20-30 minutes before slicing and serving for the best texture and flavor.
What bread should I use if I can't find a muffuletta loaf? ▼
Look for a round, dense, sesame-topped Italian or Sicilian loaf about 9-10 inches across. A sturdy focaccia or a large sesame semolina round are the closest substitutes — avoid anything too soft or airy, since it needs to hold up to the oily olive salad without falling apart.
